Maximizing Your Property Damage Claim After a Car Accident in Texas
When you’re in a car accident, the first thing that comes to mind is usually whether anyone is hurt. But often, the bigger problem in the moment is the damage to your car. Many Texans call us every week with a common question: “I was in a crash, no one was injured, but my car is wrecked. What should I do?”
At Carrollton Injury Law, we focus on injury cases — but we also know how stressful and confusing it is to deal with the property damage side of a car accident. That’s why we created this page and video guide. Even if your accident didn’t cause physical injuries, you deserve fair treatment from the insurance company when it comes to fixing or replacing your vehicle.
This page walks you through how to maximize your property damage claim, avoid common mistakes, and protect yourself if injuries show up days or weeks later. It’s our way of putting the “personal” back into personal injury law — by helping Texans even when we don’t take on their claim directly.
WERE YOU OR A LOVED ONE SERIOUSLY INJURED?
What Our Clients Say
Why Property Damage Claims Can Be Frustrating
Insurance companies often make property damage claims sound simple. They’ll tell you to get an estimate, send in photos, and wait for a check. But anyone who’s gone through it knows it’s not that easy. Common problems include:
Lowball offers: Insurers may try to pay less than your car is worth.
Delays: Weeks can pass before you hear back.
Disputes over repairs vs. total loss: Companies may push to repair when your car should really be totaled.
Rental car headaches: Insurance may cut off your rental too soon.
These frustrations are real. The good news is, with the right approach, you can often push back and secure a fairer outcome.
Step 1: Document Everything Immediately
After a car accident, documentation is your best friend. Even if there are no injuries, the steps you take right away can strengthen your property damage claim.
Call the police: Always get an accident report, even for “minor” crashes.
Take photos: Capture damage from multiple angles, skid marks, and anything in the environment that may help.
Gather info: Write down names, phone numbers, insurance details, and license plate numbers.
Note the details: Record the date, time, weather conditions, and how the accident happened.
The more proof you collect, the harder it is for the insurance company to downplay your losses.
Step 2: Understand Vehicle Valuation
Insurance companies typically use software like CCC or Mitchell to estimate your car’s value. These systems don’t always reflect the real market. For example, your car may have special features, recent upgrades, or lower-than-average mileage that make it worth more than the insurer’s number.
You can challenge their valuation by:
Researching comparable vehicles for sale in your area.
Highlighting upgrades like new tires, sound systems, or aftermarket parts.
Providing maintenance records to show your car was in excellent condition.
Remember: you don’t have to accept the first offer.
Step 3: Handling Total Loss vs. Repair
One of the biggest disputes comes down to whether your car should be repaired or declared a total loss.
Repair: If repairs cost less than the car’s value, insurance may push for fixing it.
Total loss: If repairs exceed a certain percentage (often 70–80% of value), the car is declared totaled.
If you disagree with the decision, you can request an independent appraisal or submit more evidence.
Step 4: Don’t Overlook Diminished Value
Even if your car is repaired, it may not be worth what it was before the accident. This is called diminished value. For example, a buyer will pay less for a car with an accident history.
Texas law allows drivers to pursue diminished value claims in many situations. If your car was fairly new, had low mileage, and suffered significant damage, this can mean thousands of dollars.
Step 5: Know Your Rental Car Rights
If your car is in the shop, you may be entitled to a rental vehicle while it’s being repaired. Insurance companies sometimes cut corners here by:
Limiting the daily rental budget to unrealistic amounts.
Cutting off rental coverage before repairs are finished.
Don’t hesitate to push back. You are entitled to a comparable replacement vehicle for a reasonable period.
Step 6: Watch for Delayed Injuries
Here’s a key reason we provide this resource: many people believe they’re “fine” after a crash, only to discover days or weeks later that they have whiplash, back pain, or other injuries.
Insurance companies often push you to sign property damage releases quickly. Be cautious — signing too early may hurt you if injuries develop later.
If you start to notice pain or other symptoms after your accident, reach back out to a lawyer immediately. At Carrollton Injury Law, we can guide you through the process of pursuing compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering.
Step 7: Stay Organized
Create a folder (digital or paper) where you keep:
Police reports
Repair estimates
Photos of damage
Medical notes if symptoms develop later
Insurance company letters and emails
Staying organized helps you avoid missed deadlines and supports your case if things get disputed.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Taking the first offer without question
Failing to document damages and repairs
Signing a release too quickly
Not researching diminished value
Letting the insurance company dictate everything
By avoiding these mistakes, you give yourself a stronger chance of a fair settlement.
How Carrollton Injury Law Helps Even If You Don’t Have an Injury Claim
While we don’t represent clients for property damage-only cases, we want you to feel supported and empowered.
Our mission is simple: We put Personal back into Personal Injury Law.
What to Do If Injuries Appear Later
If you start experiencing headaches, stiffness, dizziness, or other issues after your crash, don’t ignore them. See a doctor right away, and then contact a personal injury lawyer.
Even if weeks have passed, Texas law allows you to pursue an injury claim as long as you are within the statute of limitations. The earlier you act, the better.
FAQ About Property Damage After a Car Accident in Texas
Do I need a lawyer for a property damage claim?
Usually not. Most people handle these claims directly with insurance. However, knowing your rights and avoiding common mistakes is key.
How long do I have to file a property damage claim in Texas?
Generally, Texas allows up to two years to file. But it’s best to start immediately while evidence is fresh.
What if the insurance company won’t give me a fair value?
You can provide independent estimates, research comparable cars, or even request an appraisal. Persistence often pays off.
Can I still make an injury claim if I already settled my property damage?
Yes, as long as you didn’t sign a release of liability for personal injury. Always check documents carefully before signing.
What if the accident was my fault?
Your options depend on your insurance coverage, such as collision or comprehensive policies. You may still recover through your own insurer.
Final Thoughts
Property damage claims can be overwhelming, but with the right knowledge, you can stand up to the insurance company and maximize your recovery. Even if your accident didn’t cause injuries, Carrollton Injury Law is here to provide guidance and resources.
And remember: if pain, stiffness, or other symptoms appear after your accident, don’t wait. Reach out to an experienced injury lawyer who will put your needs first.
Contact Carrollton Injury Law Today for a Free Car Accident Injury Claim Evaluation
If you or a loved one has been injured in a car accident, you don’t have to go through this alone.
The Carrollton Injury Law team is here to fight for your rights and help you obtain the maximum compensation possible.
We proudly serve Carrollton, Texas, and surrounding areas.
Let us help you rebuild your life after a serious car accident.
You focus on healing—we’ll handle the rest.
Free Injury Claim Evaluation
No Fee Unless We Win